Over the past 20 years the most popular strategy for a UK corporate DB scheme has been a bulk purchase transaction with an insurer. But appetite for this market has grown so much, thanks in part to US private equity, that an increasingly large number of alternatives are available (Jose Sarmento Matos/Bloomberg)
For all the talk of its decline, the UK defined benefit market is big. $1.45tn-big, to be precise.
Over the past 20 years, the most popular strategy for a DB scheme (or a corporate one, anyway) has been to derisk by investing in liability-driven investments and then proceed to a bulk purchase transaction with an insurer. Not very exciting but it has become so common that US private equity firms have been partnering with insurers to benefit from this trend.
But that may change because there are some new kids on the block.
The horizons for the DB market have been extended both literally and figuratively with guidance, issued last year by The Pensions Regulator which oversees the UK market, giving schemes a plethora of new options instead of going to an insurer.
Tom Froggett, head of DB surplus consulting at XPS Group, told AOX corporates are questioning whether they should take the orthodox route.
He said: “Certainly on the corporate side more corporates are looking at their schemes and thinking, ‘what is the right option for us?...What's our appetite to run this pension scheme for the long term? Or do we just want to exit at the first opportunity?’”
Some of the more interesting options which have come out of the guidance are: superfunds, capital-backed solutions and sponsor-swap deals. But as we’ll see, escaping the interest of US private equity is harder than you’d think.
Superfunds
DB superfunds are a commercial vehicle which looks to consolidate schemes, essentially putting them all in one big pot.
Typically the employer pays the superfund to take on its members, which can be cheaper than the insurance route.
Matt Wilmington, chief transactions officer at the $2.1bn Clara Pensions, which he described as the “only superfund who’s written any business” has announced eight transactions and is due to announce two more by the end of 2026, boosting its AUM by a further $793.3mn.
He added that due to a superfund’s capital calculations differing from that of an insurer’s, it is able to undercut a buy-in transaction by around 5 per cent, with the timeframe possibly taking months where an insurance deal can close after two years.
The main market for superfunds used to be schemes that were unable to take on insurance deals due to cost, yet more fully-funded schemes are considering transactions as the cost savings can be shared with members.
Wilmington said the current volume of superfund deals is “much lower” than those in the insurance market, with Clara as an organisation looking to absorb between $2.6bn and $4bn a year, he added that the superfund market as a whole might write $6.6bn worth of deals a year.
“It will be smaller, but still pretty significant when you think about some of those volumes that are coming through,” he added.
The superfund itself and its investors benefit through investment returns and a maturing membership. For Clara this manifests itself as a surplus being returned to the investors at the point the relevant section is bought out in the insurance market.
Clara Pensions, which until last month was the only superfund to have passed the regulator’s assessment process, is backed by US private equity firm Sixth Street.
Capital-backed arrangements
Capital-backed arrangements - sometimes grandly called “capital-backed journey plans” - are rare, two-transactions-ever rare.
This is about reducing the reliance on the employer, rather than severing the link completely.
Usually it would involve a third party providing capital to an underfunded pension scheme and investing alongside it over a defined period of time.
Steve Collins, head of superfund at TPT said the “whole asset stack is then invested to deliver a return” with the key point being that the structure “aims to deliver a guaranteed outcome for the pension scheme and the third party capital provider will look to deliver its own returns”.
Essentially the extra money allows the scheme’s assets to be put to work harder with the aim of generating a return for the investor and allowing the scheme to achieve self-sufficiency (or opt for a full buy-out).
The most recent transaction occurred in June saw Portunes Pension Capital, which is backed by UK merchant bank Aspinall Capital Partners, providing money to two pension schemes that sit under James Neill Holdings.
Collins said the provider “only makes a profit if they over-deliver what they promised to the scheme,” adding that the system lends to the provider seeking “quite a high return”.
A joint venture between US private equity firm Carlyle and UK pensions consultant Punter Southall, named the Pension Safeguard Solution, has been looking to provide capital-backed solutions, with the 70 per cent of a scheme’s assets being invested in private credit and growth assets.
The solution seems to be quite popular among trustees, as TPT’s 2026 Trustee Pulse, which surveyed 100 trustees, had 94 per cent of respondents either strongly or somewhat agreed it was an attractive endgame solution. A greater proportion of trustees who agreed superfunds were attractive (86 per cent).
Sponsor-swap arrangements
A sponsor-swap arrangement is even more rare than a capital-backed arrangement. Only one transaction has been completed. But it was big and it was impactful.
The deal saw sponsoring employer Stagecoach transfer its $1.3bn pension scheme to a new sponsor, asset manager Aberdeen Investments.
Under a sponsor-swap deal the asset manager benefits by gaining a large portion of assets since most of those will be invested in its funds, boosting its income from fees as well as pumping up its assets under management.
Meanwhile the company sponsoring the scheme gets to exit “quickly and cleanly”, according to Alison Goudarzi of Linklaters.
AOX has learnt a number of asset managers are looking at taking on schemes as the sponsor, including Schroders.
A Schroders spokesperson said: “This is an area that Schroders has been actively working with corporate sponsors and trustees drawing on our investment capabilities in this space.”
Goldman Sachs and Insight Investment, a subsidiary of BNY, are also reportedly interested in this market.
Another looming cloud relating to all of these arrangements is the results of the UK government’s ‘sponsor sharing’ consultation.
It estimates 80 per cent of schemes are now in surplus valued at $211.6bn and is now consulting about how this could be split between employers and pension members. The results are due to be released in April 2027.
This would really benefit the asset manager in a sponsor-swap arrangement as in such arrangements they act as the scheme’s sponsor, so could have rights to some of that sweet, sweet surplus.
XPS’ Froggett said such an arrangement can “work for all parties” because the investment manager is getting the revenue on the investment mandates, thus “more of the surplus can be available for the benefit of the members of the scheme and the old employer as well”.
Goudarzi said: “The Stagecoach transaction was novel, with benefits for members and sponsors alike. Whether it becomes a template for others to follow depends on a fairly specific set of conditions, all of which need to align at once.
“But even if direct replicas are rare, the deal has already done something valuable: it has demonstrated the importance of creative thinking about endgames, and has given the industry impetus to keep innovating.”
2026 as a ‘pause’ year
So can all of these fancy new options eat the insurers lunch? Well this year it seems to have taken a nibble or two.
The pension insurance transfer market is on track to halve in value this year. So far in 2026 there will have been $22.4bn worth of insurance transactions, compared with last year where it stood at $52.4bn, according to XPS’ Bulk Annuity Market Tracker.
Froggett said the lowering insurance transaction volumes represent “clear market evidence that schemes are pausing for breath a little bit,” adding that the DB scheme deals following the results of the consultation will reveal the preferred solution.
“We don't have all the pieces of the puzzle yet. We know what the puzzle's broadly going to look like but there's still a few things to happen between now and April,” he said.