The UK’s pensions regulator has expressed concerns about AI exposure which, following the news of Jensen Huang’s affair with an alleged Chinese spy, may have proven prescient. But are Britain’s pension funds overexposed? (Ann Wang/Reuters)
UK pension funds like allocating to growth asset classes to boost their value. Asset owners love to spout the old adage that a diversified portfolio mitigates this risk. Yet when the global equity market is concentrated in one geography and, on top of that, when that one geography is concentrated in one sector such as, erm, AI, does this leave UK pension funds at risk of being caught with their trousers down?
This concern is even more relevant when the chief executives of large semiconductor companies get caught with their trousers down, get fired and send markets downwards.
It is also a worry held by The Pensions Regulator, the British pensions watchdog, which has been issuing a lot of material advising pension trustees to assess AI exposure across their whole portfolio, rather than looking at individual funds or asset classes in isolation.
Ben Gunnee, executive director of market oversight at TPR, said trustees should “challenge advisers now to understand how market developments could affect their investments under different market conditions”.
Overexposure can be in the eye of the beholder but as an example let’s look at Nest, the $91bn pension fund that the UK government set up as part of its automatic enrolment reforms.
It is the UK’s largest defined contribution pension fund.
Across equities and credit 11 per cent of Nest’s entire assets under management is exposed to 11 companies, with 6 per cent in semiconductor companies Nvidia, TSMC, Broadcom, Samsung Electronics, Micron and SK Hynix, as well as 5 per cent in the five largest hyperscalers (Amazon, Microsoft, Alphabet, Meta and Oracle).
Nvidia is often referred to as a hyperscaler but Nest said there is no overlap between the two groups in its portfolio.
Nest declined to give us the breakdown for just its equity exposure — so that we might compare it to a market index — on the basis that looking at the portfolio as a whole “provides the most meaningful context”.
Most index providers don’t publish their full exposures, but tracker funds tend to do so and if we use one as a proxy we can get somewhere. If we look at the $22bn State Street SPDR MSCI All Country World ETF then we find it has an exposure of 9 per cent to the semiconductor companies listed by Nest and 9.5 per cent to the hyperscalers – or 18.5 per cent in total. We cross-checked this with a couple of other global equity tracker funds and got similar results.
Even if we assume Nest’s 11 per cent exposure is entirely in equities (Nest says it is across credit and equities but won’t provide the breakdown) then it still means the pension fund is underweight.
When it comes to being overconcentrated around AI, it’s still the market itself that is the one to beat.